Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting 58 Main BBQ & Brew. We'd love to have your feedback!

Don't remember the name of your dish? Find it on our menu!

By submitting, you agree to our , and .

Our Latest Reviews

Samantha 4 days ago

Pepperoni Pasta with Chicken

This is, by far, the best riggies I have ever tasted. Mushrooms, pepperoni and chicken are complimented with a ala creamy sauce with a kick of spice. And the portions are so huge that I have enough for my dinner and lunch the next day. My personal favorite.

Christine 12 days ago

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich

This Place is a piece of heaven, the people the food so many memories. Ive been dining here since I was 12. Never disappointed. I love you all. Can't wait to come back and enjoy my favorite dish....Nick loves you Chicken fingers hahaha that will never change.

Donna 29 days ago

Cubano

One of the best!!!! Love the whole menu!! Depends what I'm in the mood for anything is delish!

Roger about 1 month ago

Pepperoni Pasta with Chicken

It's the best. Always have some left over for the next day.

Sandra about 1 month ago

Smoked, Fried, Grilled Wings

To die for! Nothing comes close to these wings . I'll go in swearing I'm going to try something else (everything in place is amazing) and not being able to resist these!

Lanora about 1 month ago

Smoked, Fried, Grilled Wings

These wings are delicious. I get them all the time. The flavor is intoxicating. I love the smoked wings the best. The wings are definitely one of my favorites on the menu especially paired with the onion rings. The rings have just the right amount of crisp.

Erin about 1 month ago

Quesadillas

Pulled Pork Quesadillas are the best!! They're so filling they suffice for two meals for me too!

Debbiehurd1 about 1 month ago

Buffalo or Hickory Smoked Chicken Wings

THE BEST wings EVER!!! The Mother's Day Brunch is like no other! Don't take your Momma anywhere else!!!! ❤️ The staff is outstanding! We love our 58 Main!!!! ❤️❤️❤️

Tmartiniii about 1 month ago

Memphis Mac & Cheese

I've never seen this on any other menu, and no wonder - they couldn't come close to 58's 5 Cheese wonder and the meat this puts it over the top!

Thomasborrelli about 2 months ago

Calamari Sicilian

Fresh, delicious love it as an app but love it as dish too!

Chrismoorejams about 2 months ago

Corn Bread

I hate cornbread , however 58 main has DELICIOUS corn bread i love it! And thats just the cornbread! Ive loved every meal i have ever gotten except a couple times. things got messed up wich i know will happen anywhere, however i had made a comment and was ok still eating it just wanted them to know. With in minutes i had a fresh sandwich in front of me wich didnt really ask for haha. This is how this place opperates is to try and make everyone happy and let you and your family have a great experience! I love 58 main and can not wait to go back! Also check out smokin eagle in leroy!!!

Buckwheat5058 about 2 months ago

1/2 Rack Combo (6-7 Ribs)

The ribs are awesome

Charalm1722 about 2 months ago

Potato Skins w/Cheddar Cheese

The potato skins are amazing! I know you can find potato skins anywhere, but those are just ordinary! 58 Main does it best! Also the Mac & Cheese is to die for! It tastes great as leftovers too.

Gould793 about 2 months ago

Brisket Dinner

I live this dish. It is one of my favorites! I order it evertime my husband and I come to 58 Main. I also had my husband's birthday catered. What an amazing experience. Everyone loved the food, especially the chicken wings!

Forch about 2 months ago

"The 58"

This signature samwich is fantastic

Kwebster430 about 2 months ago

Taco Choices

Love all your daily specials!

Mischiefmanaged4126 about 2 months ago

Prime Rib (Fri. & Sat. ONLY)

What HAVEN'T I tried at 58 Main?! Prime rib was the most recent, it was perfect. From the grilled chicken sandwich, the Memphis Mac and cheese, the Burgers, the salads, the apps, all soooooo amazing! There is literally something on the menu here for just about everyone. There is a charm, and warmth in the atmosphere there that can be hard to find, especially amongst chain restaurants. Definitely our first choice when we are looking to go out to eat, be it with the family for dinner, or friends for wing night, or some colleagues for lunch. 58 never disappoints.

Annarmomof3 about 2 months ago

8 oz Ribeye Steak Sandwich

I called in one day wanting a steak sandwich, thinking it was a regular like philly cheese thing, and this Gorgeous sandwich was in the box. Boom 💥 I'm in Love! So good. Just what I didn't know I needed. Other times I've usually gone with the pork nachos, which are still useful. But this, this sandwich was a Whole Nother Level. We all are missing the grill guy. You all stay safe and well, and we'll keep coming back. My son has a Serious thing for the 58 Main sandwich, he's 6'6" so when he's hungry, it's a thing that needs addressing, the 58 Main does him right every time.

Jose about 2 months ago

1/2 Rack Combo (6-7 Ribs)

Omg the best bbq food i have had.

Wjk4759 about 2 months ago

1/2 Rack Combo (6-7 Ribs)

I picked the ribs, but I have to say, I've had almost everything on the menu! The ribs are perfectly cooked and seasoned, the side dishes are plentiful and delicious. (my favorites: broasted potatoes and baked beans) Try the BBQ Sampler Appetizer for a little of everything. It's all delicious!

Rwarda61 7 days ago

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich

This is just one of the many amazing dishes 58 Main has to offer! Everything my family and I order has been amazing and we always have excellent service too! I always recommend 58 Main to people headed to the Brockport area! I hope they open back up soon, even just for takeout! We are going through BBQ withdrawal!

Mary 18 days ago

1/2 BBQ Chicken

The best! The chicken is tasty, tender, moist and the baked apples are amazing.

Alp313 29 days ago

Pulled Pork Egg Rolls

The pulled pork egg rolls are fantastic. I'm also a big fan of the potato skins. Can't wait to get back for some great food and fun after Thur night softball.

Invnys about 1 month ago

Buffalo or Hickory Smoked Chicken Wings

The best! Now can we get back to drinking. Steve

Mark about 1 month ago

Wings

The smoked wings are to die for!! We have a friend from Ohio who can't wait to visit and come to 58 Main for the wings! Loves them!! Plus, 58 Main is the present day Cheers Bar! Friendliest bar in town!

T11485 about 1 month ago

"The 58"

The 58 is my go to. Delicious sandwich that never disappoints!

Lachter about 1 month ago

1/2 Rack Combo (6-7 Ribs)

Excellent staff, amazing food. Great ambiance. Will be the first place visited again after the covid quarantine!

Laurie about 1 month ago

Pulled Pork Egg Rolls

Love these....

Kmoff3 about 1 month ago

"Fowl" Pig

Best food in Brockport! We always take our college boy out to eat there every time we come visit. Love the Mac-n-cheese and the baked apples. You never leave hungry!

Rpenders about 2 months ago

BBQ Pulled Pork Dinner

I miss this so much! I always get Mac and cheese for my side and mix some of the pulled pork into it. My favorite! Plenty for next day lunch too!

Rodgersfan about 2 months ago

Wings

Best wings I have ever eaten. Hands down! And I am pretty picky! Delicious!

Chelseaccastro about 2 months ago

Chicken Finger Mac & Cheese

I have never ever been disappointed with this food. My boyfriend and I moved in in January, we had drove out here before from Chili a couple times when we heard of it before. Now that's our number 1 spot. They DO NOT DISAPPOINT WITH ANYTHING. Fast service and the buffalo chicken finger Mac and cheese is my favorite. Huge portions and literally so much taste in every bite. I wish they were open during all of this because we miss them so much and can't wait to go there again (usually 2 nights a week) we are obsessed. Thank you guys for all you do in making your customers feel AMAZING. The many flavors of wings also come out perfect every time. 120% recommend.

Michclausen1 about 2 months ago

Smoked, Fried, Grilled Wings

These wings are by far the best wings I have ever had. I get the Zamboni sauce on the side. Perfection!!!!

Nadinesuzette about 2 months ago

14 oz NY Strip Steak

Cooked perfectly and have great sides to choose from. Always wonderful service here.

Dhtoole about 2 months ago

Quesadillas

Excellent and taste great with the Southern Tier IPA!!! And you always remove the black olives for me. Cheers and can't wait to stop in and see everyone !!! Stay safe and healthy Darlene

Smbrk102 about 2 months ago

Crispy or Grilled Chicken Salad

So many items are great but I almost always come back to the salads. Always fresh and they are definitely a meal as they are large! A close second are the wings, any style!

Rnl about 2 months ago

Pepperoni Pasta with Chicken

Perfect blend of pepperoni, chicken, bow tie pasta in a blush sauce.

Sarah about 2 months ago

Quesadillas

The best! I love these and they are my go to !!! Though everything is so yummy!!

Dfurlong about 2 months ago

BBQ Beef Brisket Sandwich

Best ever! so tender it melts in your mouth. Hugh portion! The corn bread is moist and oh so good you have to have more than one! Love it!

Nkalpin about 2 months ago

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich

Best BBQ in Rochester hands down, portions, side choices and staff are topping on the cake. If your fat, like me, and like cake...with toppings. We are forever customers!



PAST DRAWING WINNERS

May 2020:
Coming Soon

April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery 
Thousand Oaks, CA

March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD

February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA

January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC

December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL

November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA

October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR

September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA

August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA

July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY

June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA

May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY

April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA